Super Bowl champs vs. Quality Opponents

Cold, Hard Football Facts for Jan 27, 2007



As loyal readers of the Cold, Hard Football Facts are aware, we put a lot of stock in Quality Wins – how a team performs against opponents with winning records. We track these records each and every week throughout the season (our final regular-season Quality Standings can be found here).
 
As we noted after Super Bowl XLI, teams with the better record against quality competition posted a 10-1 record in the 2006 playoffs. It's the second time in our three-year history that teams with a superior mark against Quality Opponents posted a remarkable 10-1 record in postseason play.
 
The Colts were the class of the NFL in the 2006 regular season, with a 4-1 mark against Quality Opponents. Following their four postseason wins, they ended the year with an 8-1 mark against winning teams.
 
Only four Super Bowl champions have better records against quality competition. Here's how the Colts stack up historically:
 
Team
Overall Record
vs. Quality Opponents
SB Result
2003 Patriots
17-2
10-0 (1.000)
won XXXVIII
1981 49ers
16-3
6-0 (1.000)
won XVI
1972 Dolphins
17-0
5-0 (1.000)
won VII
2004 Patriots
17-2
10-1 (.909)
won XXXIX
1973 Dolphins
15-2
8-1 (.889)
won VIII
1985 Bears
18-1
8-1 (.889)
won XX
1986 Giants
17-2
8-1 (.889)
won XXI
2006 Colts
16-4
8-1 (.889)
won XLI
 
(Remember, the Cold, Hard Football Facts define a quality opponent as any team that has a winning record.)
 
The 2004 Patriots, 2003 Patriots and 1979 Steelers are the only teams in NFL history to win 10 games against quality opponents in a single season. The 1979 Steelers went 10-3 against quality opponents, topping our list for games in a single season against teams with winning records. Numerous Super Bowl teams have played 11 games against quality opponents in a single season. Only four have played more than 11:
  • 1979 Steelers (10-3, .769)
  • 1986 Broncos (7-5, .583)
  • 1992 Bills (8-4, .667)
  • 2005 Steelers (8-4, .667)
SUPER BOWL TEAMS vs. QUALITY OPPONENTS (since the AFL-NFL merger)
SB (Season)
Winner (Record)
vs. Qual. Opp.
Loser (Record)
vs. Qual. Opp.
V (1970)
Baltimore (14-2-1)
4-2 (.667)
Dallas (12-5)
4-5 (.444)
VI (1971)
Dallas (14-3)
5-1 (.833)
Miami (12-4-1)
4-2 (.667)
VII (1972)
Miami (17-0)
5-0 (1.000)
Washington (13-4)
6-2 (.750)
VIII (1973)
Miami (15-2)
8-1 (.889)
Minnesota (14-3)
5-3 (.625)
IX (1974)
Pittsburgh (13-3-1)
3-1-1 (.750)
Minnesota (12-5)
4-2 (.667)
X (1975)
Pittsburgh (15-2)
7-2 (.778)
Dallas (12-5)
5-3 (.625)
XI (1976)
Oakland (16-1)
7-1 (.857)
Minnesota (13-3-1)
3-2-1 (.600)
XII (1977)
Dallas (15-2)
7-1 (.875)
Denver (14-3)
7-3 (.700)
XIII (1978)
Pittsburgh (17-2)
7-2 (.778)
Dallas (14-5)
6-4 (.600)
XIV (1979)
Pittsburgh (15-4)
10-3 (.769)
L.A. Rams (11-8)
4-6 (.400)
XV (1980)
Oakland (15-5)
6-4 (.600)
Philadelphia (14-5)
5-4 (.556)
XVI (1981)
San Francisco (16-3)
6-0 (1.000)
Cincinnati (14-5)
6-2 (.750)
XVII (1982)
Washington (12-1)
6-1 (.857)
Miami (10-3)
6-3 (.667)
XVIII (1983)
L.A. Raiders (15-4)
7-4 (.636)
Washington (16-3)
9-2 (.818)
XIX (1984)
San Francisco (18-1)
7-1 (.875)
Miami (16-3)
8-2 (.800)
XX (1985)
Chicago (18-1)
8-1 (.889)
New England (14-6)
5-5 (.500)
XXI (1986)
N.Y. Giants (17-2)
8-1 (.889)
Denver (13-6)
7-5 (.583)
XXII (1987)
Washington (14-4)
4-1 (.800)
Denver (12-5-1)
7-4 (.636)
XXIII (1988)
San Francisco (13-6)
9-2 (.818)
Cincinnati (14-5)
7-4 (.636)
XXIV (1989)
San Francisco (17-2)
9-2 (.818)
Denver (13-6)
7-4 (.636)
XXV (1990)
N.Y. Giants (16-3)
7-3 (.700)
Buffalo (15-4)
6-4 (.600)
XXVI (1991)
Washington (17-2)
9-2 (.818)
Buffalo (15-4)
4-3 (.571)
XXVII (1992)
Dallas (16-3)
6-2 (.750)
Buffalo (14-6)
8-4 (.667)
XXVIII (1993)
Dallas (15-4)
8-2 (.800)
Buffalo (14-5)
6-5 (.545)
XXIX (1994)
San Francisco (16-3)
7-2 (.778)
San Diego (13-6)
6-4 (.600)
XXX (1995) 
Dallas (15-4)
8-2 (.800)
Pittsburgh (13-6)
5-3 (.625)
XXXI (1996)
Green Bay (16-3)
7-3 (.700)
New England (13-6) 
6-5 (.545)
XXXII (1997)
Denver (16-4)
6-3 (.667)
Green Bay (15-4)
9-2 (.818)
XXXIII (1998)
Denver (17-2)
6-1 (.857)
Atlanta (16-3)
5-3 (.625)
XXXIV (1999)
St. Louis (16-3)
3-1 (.750)
Tennessee (16-4)
6-2 (.750)
XXXV (2000)
Baltimore (16-4)
7-3 (.700)
N.Y. Giants (14-5)
5-4 (.556)
XXXVI (2001)
New England (14-5)
5-3 (.625)
St. Louis (16-3)
8-2 (.800)
XXXVII (2002)
Tampa Bay (15-4)
7-4 (.636)
Oakland (13-6)
8-3 (.727)
XXXVIII (2003)
New England (17-2)
10-0 (1.000)
Carolina (14-6)
4-4 (.500)
XXXVIII (2004)
New England (17-2)
10-1 (.909)
Philadelphia (15-4)
3-2 (.600)
XL (2005)
Pittsburgh (15-5)
8-4 (.667)
Seattle (15-4)
5-3 (.625)
XLI (2006)
Indianapolis (16-4)
8-1 (.889)
Chicago (15-4)
4-2 (.667)
 
Only 4 of 36 teams that have won post-merger Super Bowls ended the postseason with a worse record against quality opponents than the team they vanquished in the championship. These four teams are:
  • 1983 Raiders (7-4, .636) over Redskins (9-2, .818)
  • 1997 Broncos (6-3, .667) over Packers (9-2, .818)
  • 2001 Patriots (5-3, .625) over Rams (8-2, .800)
  • 2002 Buccaneers (7-4, .636) over Raiders (8-3, .727)

From our partners




Join Insider Today!
Must See Videos
2014 NFL Combine Winners
2014 NFL Combine Most Impressive Performances
2014 NFL Combine Losers

Team Pages
AFC East NFC
South
North
West

Connect With Us
Sign up for our newsletter to recieve all the latest news and updates...
Privacy guaranteed. We'll never share your info.




The Football Nation Network

© Copyright 2014 Football Nation LLC. Privacy Policy & Terms of Use
Some images property of Getty Images or Icon/SMI