Tale o' the Tape: Dungy vs. Belichick

Cold, Hard Football Facts for Oct 31, 2007



By Mark Sandritter
Cold, Hard Football Facts tape measurer to the stars
 
After being called everything from the "Game of the Millennium" to "Armageddon" to "Super Bowl 41½," Sunday's bloodbath between New England and Indy has generated more hype than we have frequent groper points at the neighborhood nudie bar. 
 
But with all due respect to Tom Brady and Peyton Manning, the success of each club in recent years owes more to two men: the head coaches.
 
Yeah, we know the story: Brady and Manning are the faces of the NFL; Manning takes up more commercial air space than a fleet of 747s; Brady gets more Brazilian trim than an Amazonian warrior goddess; and, sure, comparing the two best quarterbacks in the league would be a great read.
 
But, in a coach's league, it's the men on the sidelines who deserve the credit for leading the two most successful franchises since of the 21st century.
 
Bill Belichick came to New England at a steep price, but his success far outweighs any costs. He was a controversial figure in Cleveland and then again during his three-minute stint as the HC of the NYJ. But he has helped transform the Patriots from a playoff pretender to three-time Super Bowl winner and, in doing so, has placed his name among some of the all-time great coaches.
 
Tony Dungy, meanwhile, came to the Colts after being fired by Tampa Bay for an inability to take the next step in the postseason. Since becoming the head man in Indianapolis, Dungy has never missed the playoffs and last year achieved the ultimate goal by winning Super Bowl XLI.
 
Sunday's game will be the eighth meeting between the two teams since 2003 and will mark the latest matchup of unbeaten teams in NFL history. With potential homefield advantage implications, the Cold, Hard Football Facts zooms in on the sidelines to see who has the advantage, coaching advantage that is.
 
 
TALE o' the TAPE: DUNGY vs. BELICHICK
Category
Tony Dungy
Bill Belichick
Advantage
Years as head coach
12
13
Belichick
NFL head coaching jobs
2
3 (HC of the NYJ)
Belichick
Coaching disciples
Herman Edwards, Lovie Smith, Mike Tomlin, Rod Marinelli
 
Nick Saban, Eric Mangini, Charlie Weis, Romeo Crennel, Pat Hill
Dungy
AP Coach of the Year awards
0
1
Belichick
Alma mater
University of Minnesota
 Wesleyan University
Belichick
Coaching mentor
Chuck Noll
Bill Parcells
Dungy
Overall record
121-62 (.661)
(119-81) .595
Dungy
Road record
52-40 (.565)
55-45 (.550)
Dungy
Home record
69-22 (.758)
64-36 (.640)
Dungy
Postseason record
9-8 (.529)
13-3 (,813)
Belichick
Super Bowl rings
2 (1 as player)
5 (2 with NYG)
Belichick
Division championships
5
5
Even
Playoff appearances
9
6
Dungy
Playoff scoring differential
-16
+81
Belichick
Consecutive playoff appearances
8
4
Dungy
Record with current team
67-20 (.770)
83-37 (.691)
Dungy
Losing seasons
1
5
Dungy
10-win seasons
8
6
Dungy
Longest win streak
13
21
Belichick
Apparel choice for gameday
sweater vest
mangled hoodie
Belichick
Played in the NFL
Yes
No
Dungy
Greatest accomplishment
Turned pathetic Bucs into winning franchise
Only coach to win 3 SBs in a 4 years
Belichick
 
 
CONCLUSIONS
1. Dungy rules the regular season
When former Steelers safety Lee Flowers said Tony Dungy's Buccaneers were "paper champions. That's all they are, and that's all they're ever going to be." Most thought he was referring to Tampa Bay's assortment of trash talking players, when instead it seems Flowers was well aware of Dungy's high level of regulars eason success.
 
In fact when it comes to winning during the regular season, few have done it better than Dungy. In his 12 seasons as a head coach, Dungy has won at least 10 games eight times and has reached the playoffs in nine seasons. His .661 winning percentage is sixth all-time among coaches with 100 or more regular-season victories, behind only a series of Hall of Famers  (see the list here).
 
It has all started with winning at home, where Dungy boasts an impressive .758 winning percentage in his career and has never had a losing record at home. Even in his first year as a head coach, his 6-10 Buccaneers were 5-3 at home.
 
Dungy's string of eight consecutive playoff appearances (and nine in 11 years as a head coach) should come as no surprise; only one time has a Dungy-coached team finished with a losing record. And that losing record came in 1996, his rookie year in the NFL when he went 6-10 with the the perenially piss-poor Bucs. Coming into this season, Dungy has won at least 10 games in all five seasons as Colts head coach and totaled a .770 winning percentage in Indianapolis.
 
2. But Belichick is King of the Playoffs
Belichick doesn't quite match Dungy's success in the regular season. But there's no doubt he is one of the most successful postseason coaches of all-time. Belichick has a 13-3 record in the postseason good for an outstanding .813 (13-3) win percentage, second in NFL history only to Vince Lombardi's .900 (9-1).
 
Belichick is undefeated in the Super Bowl and in 16 playoff games with the Browns and Patriots has outscored opponents by a combined 81 points. In comparison, Dungy had only marginal success in the playoffs until last year and for his career has been outscored in the postseason by 16 points - including a 41-0 loss to the Jets in 2002.
 
In some cases, Belichick's playoff success is unmatched; he is in fact the only coach to win three Super Bowl titles in a four-year span. Belichick has one at least one playoff game in all six of his trips to the postseason, even leading the Browns to a playoff victory (over Bill Parcells' Patriots) in 1994.
 
The bottom line
Not only are Belichick and Dungy the most successful coaches in the league today, they are two of the best coaches ever. And with the current state of their franchises as the undisputed rulers of the NFL, they could have even more success this year and beyond.
 
Dungy is the author of a best selling book and trumps Belichick in nearly every regular season category, including sideline fashion. But Belichick's success in the postseason has no match this side of Lombardi and, pending a win on Sunday against the Colts, the 2007 Patriots have a chance to go down as one of the best teams ever. Cameras or not, your chances of beating Belichick in the playoffs are similar to that of a hot dog surviving an encounter with Joey Chestnut.
 
Still, while Belichick has had great success with a Hall of Fame QB in New England, Dungy fashioned a winner with guys like Shaun King and Trent Dilfer in Tampa. Belichick wasn't very successful when he had average talent in Cleveland. His pre-Tom Brady winning percentage, in Cleveland and New England, was a very un-genius like .420 (42-58), including playoffs. Dungy has only one sub-.500 season on his head-coaching resume, Belichick has five, all of them in his first six years as a coach (and four in Cleveland).
 
Who's the better coach? Right now, it's a slight edge to Belichick -- his track record as an assistant (two Super Bowls) and success as a head coach in playoffs are the tie-breaker. But it's hardly the mismatch some in the media make it out to be, where Belichick is universally proclaimed as a coach without peer. But Bill Belichick does have a peer, and his name is Tony Dungy.
 
In fact, Belichick might not even be in the argument if not for the serendipitous arrival on the scene of Brady.
 
Plus, a couple of good breaks in the playoffs and it would have been Dungy getting the nod. But it's close enough that you could give Sunday's winner the lead in this epic coaching struggle ... for this week at least.

From our partners




Must See Videos
NFL Draft Changing Cities, Moving Out Of New York City | FootballNation.com
2014 NFL Draft: No Dunking In Football
2014 NFL Combine Winners

Team Pages
AFC East NFC
South
North
West

Connect With Us
Sign up for our newsletter to recieve all the latest news and updates...
Privacy guaranteed. We'll never share your info.




The Football Nation Network

© Copyright 2014 Football Nation LLC. Privacy Policy & Terms of Use
Some images property of Getty Images or Icon/SMI